Take the best player. No cleverness.
One of the top three will be gone at pick 1. Take whoever is left, in this order — do not overthink it, and do not draft for position need in the first round.
Jahmyr Gibbs → Bijan Robinson → Ja’Marr ChaseGibbs first: Detroit put his backup Isiah Pacheco on IR Sept 1, so he’s a true every-down back with no committee behind him — and your rushing-attempt bonus pays exactly that profile, roughly +3 a game before a yard is gained. Chase has a minor hyperextended knee from Aug 25, limited in practice this week, but his coach is optimistic. Not disqualifying.
Puka NacuaYour sheet says “HAPPY TAKE” at 1.02. I disagree at pick 2. He is healthy, is not suspended, and avoided the Commissioner’s Exempt List — but the league’s review of his case is still open as of today, and a mid-season suspension is live. That is a risk you can absorb in round 4, not at second overall.